The Pros and Cons about Torture
The origins of Torture:
Torture was first use in 530 AD by the Romans and ever since the world has use it. It was first used for criminal punishment. Over time torture has evolved to be use as a way to get information out about secret plots or animation about terrorist group. The use of torture really ramped up after 9/11, Americans were scared and didn't feel safe. In reaction to 9/11 the use of torture was authorized by Bush and the CIA and the military were using now more then ever. The question of should torture be use didn't pop up until the Abu Ghraib Prison incident. The Abu Gharib torture incident is the CIA and the Army committing hideous acts against their detainees, humans rights violation. More information can be found in this link: Torture at Abu Ghraib. Even with incident exposing how torture can become so hideout, it is still like that elephant in the room. For this article I planned on listing the pros and cons of both sides and for the reader to decide if torture should be use or not.
The Pros:
|
The Cons:
|
Information received
is used for a variety of purposes
|
Torture impractical
and ineffective
|
Obtain
information a timely fashion
|
Information may
be false
|
May receive information
not even asked for
|
High rates of
attrition in the interrogators
|
Can prepare for
an attack
|
Torture methods
are immoral
|
Terrorists deserve
punishment for the extra pain and misery they caused
|
Widens the anti-American
view
|
A chance of a
detainee being innocent
|
|
Other non-torture
methods are just as effective
|
(Here is a clip of Jon Stewart talking about the use of torture)
All the information is needed to know about torture, now it is time to decide:
sources: http://thejusticecampaign.org/?page_id=175
http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2004/05/10/torture-at-abu-ghraib
http://www.debate.org/torture/
http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2004/05/10/torture-at-abu-ghraib
http://www.debate.org/torture/
No comments:
Post a Comment